Watch: What happens now after Lindsay Clancy trial jurors deadlocked again?

September 2, 2026

Jurors deliberating in the murder trial of Lindsay Clancy have reported being unable to reach a unanimous decision for the second consecutive day. Following the deadlock announcement on Wednesday, Judge William Sullivan instructed the jury to continue their discussions and read them the Tuey-Rodriguez instructions, which are designed to encourage consensus while allowing jurors to maintain their individual convictions. The jury is now on its fifth day of deliberations in this case.

Who is affected

Lindsay Clancy (the defendant on trial for murder)
The jury members deliberating the case
Judge William Sullivan (presiding over the trial)

What action is being taken

Jurors are continuing private deliberations after being instructed by the judge
Judge William Sullivan is reading Tuey-Rodriguez instructions to the jury to encourage them to reach a unanimous verdict

Why it matters

This case matters because a jury's inability to reach a unanimous verdict after multiple days of deliberation could result in a mistrial, which would mean the case may need to be retried entirely with a new jury, delaying justice and requiring significant additional court resources and time.

What's next

The jury is returning to continue private deliberations. (Note: While the article mentions the possibility of a mistrial, this is not stated as a definitive next step, only as a potential outcome if deliberations remain deadlocked.)

Read full article from source: BBC